000 02242nam a2200157Ia 4500
008 180524s2013 CNT 000 0 und d
245 1 0 _aSpatial transgression of new religious sites in Israel
500 _aDOI: 10.1016/j.apgeog.2013.02.002
520 3 _aReligion and the expansion of religious sites throughout the built environment have a long and conflict-ridden history. This paper examines the development of three controversial religious sites in Israel that have developed in recent decades in an effort to better understand the kinds of political, social, and locational circumstances that cause some new sites to be regarded as spatially transgressive. The three sites examined here are the Mormon Center in Jerusalem, the Baha'i Gardens in Haifa, and the Church/Mosque in Nazareth. The study is based primarily on 75 structured, open interviews with stakeholders and decision-makers.The broader aim of the paper is to generate a better understanding of the concept of spatial transgression through systematic investigation based on the methodology of “framing.” This methodology provides a comprehensive vocabulary for perceptions, referred to as “frames,” and offers a detailed and systematic typology of frames based on the literature and the empirical data (grounded research) of the case studies.The main findings fall within the three aggregated super-frames identified in the research: “Process,” “Values,” and “Issues.” Of these, the Process super-frame was found to be dominant in all three cases. Comparing the different frames in the three cases enabled us to identify the factors that influenced the transgression process. It also facilitated a better understanding of the different “stories” involved and the concept of spatial transgression, which was found to exist on a scale ranging from low to high intensity. This paper also proposes a framing typology that may prove useful for understanding and mapping similar cases elsewhere.
690 _aSpatial transgression
700 1 _aBen Gal, Michal
700 1 _aCollins-Kreiner, Noga
700 1 _aShmueli, Deborah F.
773 _tApplied Geography
_g40 Complete, 103-114
856 4 1 _3PDF
_ainternal-pdf://3110638767/collinskreiner2013.pdf
999 _c23941
_d23941